The Future of Fan Ownership at Partick Thistle Football Club – A Roadmap 

The Future of Fan Ownership at Partick Thistle Football Club – A Roadmap 

 

As Partick Thistle fans begin their journey as owners of their beloved Club it is important that we demonstrate a clear path towards an inclusive, democratic and representative fan ownership model. 

 

To that end the PTFC Trust, The Jags Foundation, The Jags Trust, Proud Jags and other fan representatives met in December. All discussions were amicable and there was a clear consensus on the goals we ultimately wished to achieve. 

 

A Working Group was set up to prepare proposals to present to the majority shareholders (the PTFC Trust). The Working Group was made up of representatives of the PTFC Trust, TJF, The Jags Trust and the John Lambie stand fans. We were assisted in the early stages of our discussions by Garry Halliday of the Foundation of Hearts and Alan Russell of Supporters Direct Scotland. We would all like to formally thank Alan and Garry for sharing their advice and experience. 

 

On Hogmanay the proposals were shared with the Trustees of the PTFC Trust. During January the proposals were examined and clarifications sought and given. 

 

We are now pleased to present our roadmap to genuine fan ownership to the entire Partick Thistle support. 

 

The full document can be viewed. 

 

The main changes to the PTFC Trust include the following: 

 

1.     Add two corporate trustees, namely TJF, and The Jags Trust. (See below)  

 

2.     Recognising that the Trust becomes a passive holder of shares, which also protects the asset similar to a Holding company. 

 

3.     Redefine PTFC Trust beneficiaries as season ticket holders, members of TJF, and members of The Jags Trust. At the same time, make a beneficiaries class in TJF and TJT by amending articles so democracy can be delivered to beneficiaries through existing infrastructures. 

 

4.     Make provision for the current PTFC Trust trustees to step away at such time that they are confident and comfortable that everything is operating as it ought to. Therefore, ultimately the Trust would have two trustees, namely the two largest fans organisations, The Jags Trust, and The Jags Foundation.  

 

5. Add a clause to Trust deed that mirrors article 42 in the Articles of Association of TJF.  

Namely, compelling certain actions (selling stadium or part thereof) to require a beneficiary  

vote with 75% majority vote. 

 

All involved are proud to present these proposals to Partick Thistle fans. We hope they demonstrate a clear route to genuine fan ownership and that they are accepted in the coming months. 

 

Joint Update on Future of Fan Ownership from The PTFC Trust, The Jags Trust and The Jags Foundation

As previously intimated, the Short Life Working Group met during December and put a paper to the Trustees by 31 December. This group was independently chaired and worked together well.

There has now been initial consideration of this by The Trustees, resulting in a few clarifications being required. The Short Life Working Group have met again to agree the responses to those clarifications.

Shortly, representatives from the Working Group will meet The Trustees to feedback these responses face to face, and conclude any further dialogue and queries.

In the spirit of co-operation and working together, once agreed, this will then be presented to the football club Board to ensure that they have no further questions.

We expect this process to be complete by mid-February.

All fans groups involved would like to thank all members of the working group, the Trustees for their consideration and time, and the Club Board for their ongoing dialogue during this phase.

We also thank you all for your trust and patience, as we dot the i’s and cross the t’s on an appropriate fan ownership model for our club.

Statement by The Jags Trust. Trading name of The Partick Thistle Supporters Association

Partick Thistle Supporters Association t/a The Jags Trust exists by virtue of the Save The Jags campaign, without which there would not be a Partick Thistle today.

It has a shareholding (diluted but still 7%) held on behalf of and for the benefit of Thistle fans, has been an important one in terms of ensuring that fan voices are heard, for more than a decade in the Club Board Room and also at Annual General Meetings, EGMs and all major decision-making by the shareholders.

The Jags Trust, like The Jags Foundation, believe that Thistle should join other clubs in Scottish football in blending a professionally-run club with fan ownership, genuine and guaranteed representation in the Board Room at all decision-making levels and enhanced consultation with the lifeblood of all clubs - their fans!

Colin Weir presented Partick Thistle fans with a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. If we get it right, Thistle fans can become the ultimate custodians of our Club, bringing long-term stability, safeguarding it for future generations, and helping it to thrive on and off the park.

Our organisations have complimentary strengths.

The Jags Foundation, by contrast holds no shares in the Club. However it has mobilised more than 630 fans behind a membership subscription model, in the space of just 9 months. This is after 30 months of hard graft by the working groups, which included representatives of the Jags Trust.

The Jags Foundation has the momentum and engagement with the fan base, membership now exceeds 900, that is necessary to make majority fan-ownership work.

The potential for synergy is obvious.

We believe that, by having our organisations continuing their dialogue and working together, Thistle fans will be better served in building the legacy of a community-owned football club of which we can all be proud.

Both organisations are committed to identifying and promoting a common vision of what fan ownership really means.

It has been a huge disappointment that representatives of the Jags Trust and The Jags Foundation have not been named as the suitable vehicle, in their discussions with 3BC, to become the majority shareholders in Partick Thistle since we share an aspiration.

Jags Trust AGM

The Jags Trust AGM will take place on Monday 4th July at 7pm. This meeting will take place online via Zoom. Please see below for full details on how to join the AGM.

Donald Larmour is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting.

Topic: Jags Trust AGM

Time: Jul 4, 2022 07:00 PM London

Join Zoom Meeting

https://us04web.zoom.us/j/74458254295?pwd=cvFgjJhXS8VT0rLaAnRRSiDzWaIkdC.1

Meeting ID: 744 5825 4295

Passcode: Archie

Club Development Scotland - August Newsletter

News & What We're Reading

Free 'Equality through Sport' workshop provision for sports clubs across Scotland

Our friends at the Fair Play Foundation have provision to deliver 50 'equality through sport' workshops to clubs across Scotland. 

If you run a sports club, coach at your local team or volunteer with a sports organisation, we’d love to hear from you.

The workshops are delivered at a time and location convenient to your club for what should be an enjoyable, thought provoking and hopefully a stimulating experience for all involved.

"I've attended the Colours of our Scarves workshop a few times now and find it extremely beneficial and informative. It has been a great Continued Professional Development tool for our developing coaches increasing confidence and challenging hate behaviours" - Nichola Sturrock, Spartans FC. 

Annual Deaths Due To Physical Inactivity Still Outstrip Covid

More people are still dying every year around the world due to physical inactivity than have been killed by the Covid-19 pandemic.

That is one of the stark facts reported in the latest three-paper series published by The Lancet medical journal as researchers call for urgent action to increase physical activity, particularly to arrest adolescent decline. It reports that global efforts to improve physical activity have stalled, with overall deaths caused by physical activity remaining at more than 5 million people, per year. 

Community coaching structure expected to be severely hit by COVID

Research commissioned by the Sport and Recreation Alliance has shown that several organisations are expected to lose a significant number of their paid coaching workforce as physical activity re-emerges from lockdown.

 

Funding For Your Club

'Clubs in Crisis' fund

The Clubs in Crisis Fund re-opened on the 23rd July.

The Clubs in Crisis Fund from Made by Sport supports sports clubs and organisations delivering sport for development that have been negatively affected by the Covid-19 pandemic.

This is a national fund being delivered locally by community foundations across the UK. Foundation Scotland is distributing all funding across Scotland.

The fund aims to support sports clubs and youth organisations that deliver sport for development to recover from the pandemic's impact, and continue their work to achieve social outcomes through sport.

Specifically, the fund is looking to support clubs and organisations that intentionally deliver wider social outcomes through sport.

These outcomes must fall into one or more of the following categories: - Developing Life Skills - Improving Mental Health - Reducing Crime and Anti-Social Behaviour - Developing Employability Skills - Building Stronger Communities Funding is unrestricted but should clearly meet the criteria of delivering sport for development for young people.

All funding must be spent by successful applicants between 1st October and 31st December 2021.

 

 

Resources For Your Club

Taking control of your assets can help your club grow; develop new opportunities; secure their future and be more engaged with local people and organisations.

An interactive guide has been developed to help you understand your community rights. The guide is based on a written report authored by Dr. Adam Brown, Substance and Tom Hall, Sporting Assets. Download the full guide by clicking here.

 

 

Testimonials

Glasgow Saints

"When we formed Glasgow Saints Football Club in 2020, we knew very early on that we wanted to be a club that existed to support our community as much as our community would support us. This is what drove us to become a registered charity in Scotland. We understood what becoming a charity would mean in simple terms, but as individuals we had no real experience or understanding of the process involved; or understanding of the full scope of how we could use registration to further benefit those we were eager to help.

Club Development Scotland guided us seamlessly through every stage of the process, answered every question we had and introduced options that without them, we would never have known existed. Being able to rely on their expertise and trusting in their counsel, also afforded us the time to focus our efforts on other areas of club development, allowing for continual internal growth. Our sincerest thanks to Andrew and the team for their patience, and for turning a daunting task into an enjoyable one for all on the Board at GSFC."

– Emma Jones, Trustee

 

Fundraising

 Fundraising is an important aspect of any club's success. Check out some ways you can raise valuable income here. If you're looking for support with your fundraising, get in touch.

 

Fantastic Fanatics

Fantastic Fanatics (FF) is a great new way to raise funds for your club, at no extra cost, when you shop, eat out, book hotels and lots more.

Clubs can sign up to the FF platform here and start earning money straight away - don't forget to select Club Development Scotland as your governing body for an extra 10% income. 

SNAP Sponsorship Support

SNAP helps clubs promote sponsorship opportunities to a wider audience while sharing best practices when it comes to negotiating and securing sponsorship, all within one easy-to-use platform. Use the promo code "clubdevelopmentscotland" at checkout and enjoy 12 months of support for the price of 11 (+ keep 100% of your sponsorship)

Programme Notes - 31/07/21

The Jags Trust is delighted to present the Managers Preview on all social media platforms.

As the curtain (flag) is raised the audience of Jags fans get the opportunity to applaud the

cast. We celebrate with Ian and his players their amazing achievement in Season 2020-2021

of winning League One and returning Partick Thistle to the SPFL “Cinch” Championship.

Good Luck and fingers crossed for an exciting and successful Season 2021-2022.

Although we have not yet reached the finish line for social distancing, we are pleased to hear

from the Club so many have committed themselves to season tickets to ensure entry to

Firhill. We are thinking of all those who are still required to stay at home, for health reasons

or loss of confidence, and hope you will soon be back amongst your Firhill family.

Jags supporters have stoically supported the club throughout these very strange and difficult

times. Unfortunately, as I write, there are still question marks over the feasibility for travelling

support to the next two matches. Keep your eye out for updates from the bus convenors or

www.ptfc.co.uk.

The new membership year has now begun. If you don’t already have a standing order in

place, it’s time to renew your Jags Trust membership. Thanks to everyone who has already

renewed their membership and remind others that it’s never too late to sign up.

Visit www.jagstrust.com “The Shop” for the membership form; handmade Red, Yellow &

Black jewellery and the famous book Red & Yellow For Ever author Robert Reid, Club

Historian.

Supporters Direct Scotland www.supporters-direct.scot and Club Development Scotland

www.clubdevelopment.scot catch up with news and surveys for football supporters from

around Scotland and Europe.

The Jags Trust Board welcomes to Firhill, physically or via live stream, the Chairperson,

Office Bearers and Committee Members of Queen of the South FC and the “Doonhamers

Supporters Trust” for Season 2021 - 22, SPFL “Cinch” Championship opening match.

Morag McHaffie

Chairperson PTSA “The Jags Trust” and Supporters Direct Scotland Council

Supporters Direct Newsletter July 2021

WE'RE BACK WHERE WE BELONG!

The last 17 months have been hard for everyone around the world, with every aspect of our lives impacted by COVID-19. Football was no exception, and we have been denied the chance to support our teams and spend time with our fellow fans.

It was difficult at times not to jump on the bandwagon and demand an early return for fans to attend matches, but we were acutely aware that doing so could increase the number of cases and ultimately deaths. This was one (rare!) time when football was NOT more important than life and death. Instead, we took a more cautious approach, working behind the scenes with other stakeholders across the game to ensure that when it was time to return it would be done as safely as possible, and that in the meantime our clubs were able to survive. That time is now.

Supporters around the country backed their clubs financially despite there being no prospect of watching their teams play; the SFA and various league bodies  accelerated scheduled payments to clubs; philanthropists (most notably James Anderson) donated massive sums of money through the SPFL Trust and directly to leagues and clubs; and the Scottish Government approved a programme of loans and grants to clubs across the country. It is testament to all of these actions that our professional game is still intact and that none of our clubs have experienced an insolvency event. In our opinion that is a minor miracle, and one that we should all be immensely proud of.

Now is the time when we can #letfansin! At first this is happening in limited numbers, but this week's decisions to allow Celtic, Aberdeen and Hibernian (and hopefully many others) to welcome larger crowds demonstrates a shared commitment to taking careful steps towards a broader lifting of restrictions. The decision-making process is not yet transparent enough, and this will frustrate many of us - but with 32 local authorities each making decisions to keep their own communities safe, and every football ground being different, this frustration is likely to continue for some time.

If crowd restrictions at your club's matches mean that it is difficult for you to attend, now is the perfect time to pay other clubs a visit. One of our lockdown projects was to create an interactive map with information about all of Scotland’s football grounds. We shared the data behind the map with a UK-wide project called LetFansIn and it is also available on their website. Many of us have dozens of football clubs on our doorsteps, playing in the 5th, 6th and 7th tiers of our game, who we have never been to. Every one of these clubs has suffered during COVID-19, and would love to see more of you on a Saturday afternoon. COVID-19 protection measures will be in place at every one of these grounds, so stay safe and enjoy your football wherever you manage to see it! 

 

Yes Sir, We Boogied!

After a 23 year absence it was amazing to see the Scotland men's national team in the finals of a major tournament again! We would all have hoped to cheer the team on in more than three matches, but just being there was fantastic, and the performance at Wembley in particular was everything we had hoped for.

Well done to every member of the Tartan Army for your impeccable conduct at all three matches. You make us proud every time we play.

 

Stenhousemuir FC and the pandemic

As part of 2020's research project on volunteer management in Scottish football, funded by our friends at SD Europe, we spoke to Stenhousemuir FC about their "Community Help Initiative". We saw this as a fantastic demonstration of how quickly and powerfully a football club can respond to community need if everyone is aligned around a shared purpose and direction.

Our research project was originally intended to include visits to each club featured in the project report, and we had to wait a little longer to do this! But we were delighted to eventually sit down with Stenhousemuir's chairman Iain McMenemy to hear more from him about their work in the community. You can see what he had to say in the video below, and read the full report including more case studies here.

 

Tap Out and take a moment to avoid Bet Regret

With the new season underway we are delighted to be renewing our partnership with GambleAware, helping them to implement their “Bet Regret” campaign for the 2021/22 season. Bet Regret is the sinking feeling you get the minute you make a bet without thinking it through. Often when drunk, bored or chasing losses. It’s about avoiding those impulsive bets you kick yourself for as soon as you’ve made them.

Our matchday experiences are full of habits – who we go with, where we go before the game, and often superstitions like wearing our lucky pair of socks! Betting is also a habit – putting a line on or picking matches for an accumulator. This makes Saturdays about more than just the match, and we want to build good habits that make it more enjoyable rather than something we regret.

“Tap out and take a moment” is a simple tip to use every time you bet. Tap out of your betting app before you place a bet and then take a moment to think – this could be by making a cup of tea, deciding what you want for dinner or just by putting your phone down for a minute. This gives you time to really think it through and decide if it’s a bet you should avoid or not.

We have seen the return of fans in limited numbers this month for the group stage of the league cup, and look forward to the gradual lifting of COVID restrictions as the league fixtures begin. The football’s back, the fans are back, but the Bet Regret is not back. This season, tap out and take a moment to avoid Bet Regret. 

 

Help us strengthen Scottish football

 

Like most organisations, the financial pressures on SD Scotland intensified during the COVID-19 pandemic, and posed a real threat to our ability to continue our work with supporters groups and grassroots sports clubs. Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic we began re-thinking our business model, and were working to expand our commercial activities. Our goal was, and remains, to reduce our reliance on grant funding whilst continuing to advocate for greater supporter engagement and involvement in the governance of our clubs and of the national game.

However, the commercial environment has changed and this has impacted us significantly. We have therefore expanded our Patreon crowdfunding programme, and any contributions (as small or as large as you can afford) that you are able to make to our work will make a massive difference to us. We have introduced three new tiers, with merchandise featuring our "football without fans is nothing" graphic in order for us to recognise your contributions:

  • Bronze tier supporters (donating £5 per month) will receive a sticker

  • Silver tier supporters (donating £12.50 per month) will receive a coffee mug

  • Gold tier supporters (donating £20 per month) will receive a t-shirt

Patreon supporters automatically become Associate Members of SD Scotland:

  1. You’ll be joining a network of fans and supporters groups working to ensure that supporters' voices are heard and influence positive change within the game.

  2. Receive regular updates on issues affecting Scottish football and/or its fans.

  3. Get free access to our events such as Annual Supporters Summit.

  4. Get involved in the democratic structures of Supporters Direct Scotland as one of our three Associate Directors.

Sign up as a Patreon supporter here.

 

 

And finally...

 

Articles, podcasts and videos from the archive

As part of our objective to better connect fans, share best practice within Scottish sport, to promote supporter dialogue and promote sport clubs through which positive societal change can occur, here we share some relevant recent stories.

  1. Celebrating A Good Week For The SFA & Scots Sides In Europe

  2. Crowds, Scotland Women’s Potential New Boss and Peterhead’s Vaccine Drive

  3. It Will Be A Great Start To League Season With Fans Back In The Stands!

  4. Well Done, Motherwell FC And It’s Supporters!

  5. Celebrating Bertie Auld!

  6. Gilmour The Great

  7. Superb Scottish Euro 2020 Content

  8. Looking At Scotland’s Positive Dutch Performance

 

You can also check out our back catalogue of podcast episodes and subscribe to Behind The Goals using your favoured ‘podcatcher’ here, and subscribe to our YouTube channel here.